19 May 2007 04:21

SOMALIA WATCH

 
Column
  • Title: [SW Column] ( SW - Nadamudin Elm) CHARACTER FLAWS OF THE SOMALIS
  • Posted by/on:[AAJ][1 Jan 2001]
  •  
  • Opinions expressed in this column are those of the contributors and not necessarily those of SW.



    CHARACTER FLAWS OF THE SOMALIS

    by Nadamudin Elmi  nadamudin@hotmail.com





    Conventional wisdom these days is uniform when it comes to describing
    Somalis, they are irrational, dishonest, difficult people determined to
    self-destruct and very much still capable of taking with them to the abyss
    anyone who attempts to alleviate their condition.

    The lives of eighteen American, 25 Pakistani soldiers and countless Somali
    casualties sealed that fate, and the rest of the world pretty much put
    Somalia in a shelf with a sign that says, "never to be touched again."

    One can accuse Somalis of many things; what they are not, however, is
    uninformed about their situation or about world affairs. Somalis thrive on
    news, it is the first thing they ask of each other when they meet (maxaa la
    sheegay?), and no self-respecting Somali goes to bed at night before
    listening to the latest bulletin from the BBC.  Thus, it is a forgone
    conclusion that they are aware of what the rest of the world thinks of them,
    or what is the nature of their problem.

    Given that there is minimal outside influence on Somali affairs, one would
    think that they would finally get their acts together, take stock of the
    reality around them, realize the facts on the ground and the parity
    established where no tribe can unilaterally impose its will on others. One
    would think that they would start dealing with each other as equals instead
    of using long debunked arguments about the sanctity of the Somali Union,
    especially when such arguments are coming from those who were primarily
    responsible for causing the collapse of the Somali State.

    The flipside of that argument comes from those who advocate and assert that
    the Somaliland independence is irreversible without taking into account that
    such question was never posed to the Somaliland populace in a form of a
    referendum, while at the same time ignoring the sentiment of a generation of
    Somalis who grew up with the notion that Hargeysa is theirs just as much as
    Kismayo even though they never set foot on either. Furthermore, facts on the
    ground lead one to believe that today the Sool region in Somaliland is no
    longer playing the secession tune.

    Now the two questions with obvious answers that are not being raised here by
    both camps are:

    Can warlords and shady characters with a possible criminal record put the
    Somali State together? Can there be an independent Somaliland without Sool
    or consent from the rest of the Somali people?

    These questions are not being addressed because they point out the
    weaknesses of each of those arguments and therefore are best left alone by
    all concerned. However, simply stated the answers lies in our being honest
    with each other and our ability to search our souls for the common good;
    neither Somali unity nor Somaliland independence can be achieved by ignoring
    the opposing viewpoint.  Eritrea did not gain its independence until a newly
    born government in Ethiopia was willing to grant that wish. And the powerful
    empire of Haile Selassie could not maintain Ethiopian unity. Given these
    very real and close examples it seems irrational why are we still falling on
    delineated predictable lines?

    This is where our character comes into play, and it seems that we can't help
    ourselves but be true to our nature, which by all indications dictates
    immediate gratification and short-term gains above all.  Having lost any
    sense of shame which was the one saving grace that kept an individual from
    crossing long established lines, it became remarkably easy for most to let
    loose a lower form of self into the community to pursue selfish goals.
       To this end we are willing to sacrifice principle, integrity, the truth
    and lately even our new found faith in our religion

    For instance, there are a large number of Somali women wearing the "Xijaab"
    these days, and the mosques in my neighborhood are overflowing with Somali
    worshipers This faith revival would lead one to believe a righteous
    community is taking root here. However, upon closer examination one will
    find that it is not uncommon for these "Xijaabed" sisters to claim to their
    social worker that all of their children are illegitimate in order to
    extract as much as possible from the social welfare system. The fact that
    they are strictly following the teachings of the Quran to the extent of
    living by its commands (wearing the xijaab, prayers, etc.) and their
    deliberate lies to gain something which they are not justified to receive
    does not register with them as sinful, nor does it pose for them any ethical
    dilemmas or moral issues.

    Why is that? Why is it that we are willing to do or say just about anything
    in order to satisfy our immediate need whether real or imagined?

    The answer may lie in our primal culture, which is deeply rooted in the
    cycle of the nomadic way of life developed over the years, where feast and
    famine are accepted realities of life. Unlike a farmer who invests time and
    labor on the land and waits to reap his reward at harvest time, a nomad
    simply moves on to find better pastures after depleting whatever resources
    available to him. The only factor at play for the nomad is the present and
    the future is perceived just like the rain he depends on, as something
    beyond his control.

    This predisposition to take life one day at a time and make the most of it
    is very much a contributing factor to why a comprehensive peace agreement
    still eludes us. While some form of a comprehensive peace agreement
    encompassing all Somalis that reflects the realities on the ground is not
    something beyond our reach, giving up whatever little powers each group has
    today for the possibility of a better tomorrow for all is something we are
    simply not programmed to do.

    It is just not in our nature!

    Nadamudin Elmi

    You may address your comments here:
    nadamudin@hotmail.com


    [Column]

    Copyright © 1999 by somaliawatch.org.  All Rights Reserved.  Revised:  19 May 2007 05:09 AM. Webmaster HomePage