The Effect of Fake Shillings on the Economy and
the Poor
Arlaadinet (14 Feb 2001) - The recent
unanticipated hyperinflation has done substantial harm to economic
efficiency and equity. Whereas 11 000 shillings would buy a dollar
on last Wednesday, 15 000 were needed on this Wednesday, the
currency's all-time low. The inflation rose high horribly decreasing
the value of Somali Shilling. Inflation is again rampant and the
price of everyday goods has soared, leading to demands that this
practice to be put to an end once and for all. Such a reckless
exercise might renew violence if food prices increased sharply. It
hurts millions of people while few individuals benefited.
While inflation is quite common to many economies
but anticipated inflation creates fewer problems compared to
unanticipated hyperinflation. Since 1991 there have been a number of
attempts by factional leaders to print new banknotes, with which
they could fund their rise in power and influence. Somali currency
was printed, especially during UNOSOM’s presence, but traders were
usually aware of its existence, and the amounts printed were never
enough to cause major concern.
The latest banknote shipment printed in Indonesia
marked the seventh time in four years that businessmen have imported
Somali shillings and has caught people by surprise. Somalia may soon
face similar situation of Germany, Poland and Hungary faced in the
1920s. To buy a handful of groceries, they needed a shopping cart of
currency. If that happens the Somali currency may soon collapse.
Businessmen and "freelance" operators
along with warlords have run the country, which does not have banks.
Privatizing the national currency in this way can eventually have
serious negative impacts on the economy, especially if it means
dollarization. There was complete freedom of the foreign exchange
market, the Somali shilling rules between Kenya and the Horn, with
only a small part of the Northwest region using the SlSh. Therefore,
apart from this area, there is a common market, and monetary union.
If the Somali shilling is destroyed, there may be a delay before the
dollar takes over.
The most affected are small traders and thousands
of internally displaced people (IDPs) in Mogadishu. Majority of IDPs
was dislocated from their farms and houses in Lower Shabelle and
sought refuge in Mogadishu by making makeshift homes in abandoned
government buildings. With the latest influx of fake currency they
are in verge of starvation.
Without bargaining power as employee and lack of
government to look after them, the IDPs are left to the mercy of
ruthless businessmen. These people are systematically denied their
right to lead a normal life by depriving the essential daily ration
through inflated prices. This act constitutes gross human rights
violation.
Assigning the Culprit
Four different local currencies circulate in
Somalia, introduced by different political and regional groups. On
several occasions since then new bank notes printed by various
warlords have come into circulation.
In 1996, Mohamed Farah Aydiid struck a deal with a
Canadian printing company and a Malaysian (Adorna) intermediary for
a massive number (165 million) of new banknotes. He received the
first consignment, and used this to maintain the strength of his
alliance. More recently, his son, Hussein, tried to do the same.
In 1997, warlord Hussein Mohammed Aidid had
millions of dollars worth of shillings minted in Canada and used
them to pay for his gunmen and supporters to maintain his illegal
occupation of fertile land of Bay region and Lower Shabelle.
The interim government is reported to receive a
cut of the proceeds from such deals and it relies on this percentage
to pay civil servants, and rent for its offices. But though the
money may keep the interim government afloat, it has ruined the
fragile economy that operates in Mogadishu and in other regional
centers including Baidoa and Bossaso.
This is the second time that the interim
government becomes involved with the importation of fake currency.
Last October businessmen close to the TNG imported planeload of fake
shillings. It was reported A/qasim Salat, the interim president,
personally ordered the use of the money despite the protest from
some of his cabinet member.
On Tuesday, some of Mogadishu dailies reported
that the interim prime minister, Mr. Galaydh, struck a deal with the
money dealers and agreed to transfer 60 billions shillings to the
government. At the same time the TNG issued press release condemning
this reckless practice. The hypocrisy of TNG is apparent from; first
its claim of not being involved in this shameful exercise while
controlling the airport used to money trafficking, secondly, it is
reliance on businessmen who are responsible for the trade of illicit
currency. TNG use of new shillings for its expenses has similar
effect - it will not bring any productivity to the economy.
Malaysia, Indonesia and Canada are the popular
countries that allowed the few Somali businessmen to profit from
this unholy business in the expense of millions of poor families.
Indonesian company, Pt. Pura Baru Kudus, is
involved in printing new Somali bank notes in Jawa of Indonesia. It
is said that more than US $ 4 million worth of Somali bank notes is
being printed under fake license and authority from non-existing
Somali government. While Malaysian and Canadian companies also
printed and facilitated the shipment of large quantity of illicit
currency.
Notorious businessman Mohamed Abdulle Daylaaf and
his infamous counterpart Hussein Goley are among several businessmen
who are responsible for importation of fake shillings on several
occasions.
Conclusion
Whether the Somali shillings is collapsed or has a
chance to be rescued is depends on how people resist against the
fake currency and what TNG will do with the money that is
transferred to her. With Somalia's collapsed economy, almost 99% of
unemployment rate with majority of the people have no assets, the
circulation of newly printed fake money into the market will do
irreversible damage to the economy and to the people specially the
poor.
It's early days TNG reiterated that the government
is for the poor. To date it has failed to live to its promise.
Before six months 1USD was exchanged with less than 1000 shillings.
Now the shillings lost 40% of its value. The new fake currency must
not be allowed to enter the market (burning is the only option) and
those responsible (businessmen and TNG officials) must be tried for
crime against humanity.
On the other hand, a new currency may be
introduced. Replacement of the national currency with dollars, or a
new currency will, therefore, have a negative impact on business (by
raising the cost of transactions), and on the poorest sections of
the Somali population (due to inflation first, and the
indivisibility of the US dollar in the country). There are also
political costs to creating a new monetary union, which can hardly
be afforded at this time.
___________________________________________________________________________________
SOMALIA: Government to buy up
imported money
NAIROBI, 14 February (IRIN)
- The Transitional National government (TNG) of Somalia
will buy newly minted money from the businessmen who imported it to
try and control its impact on the economy. This was announced on
Tuesday by the Prime Minster's Office, a senior official told IRIN.
The government will buy 60 billion
Somali shilling, about US $4 million dollars. In return, the
businessmen involved have undertaken not to import any more money,
the official said. In a move to fight the importation of newly
printed money the government will soon announce the creation of a
central bank, and the appointment of its senior officers, he said.
Since 7 February, five planes
arrived with consignments of newly printed Somali bank notes -
reportedly from Malaysia - for a cartel of Somali businessmen. The
money has caused hyper-inflation with local markets shutting down,
and serious fluctuations in the exchange market, a local economist
told IRIN.
Interim Prime Minster Ali Khalif
Galaydh, threatened legal action against those who try to import
more money, Deutsche Presse-Agentur (DPA) said. "Whoever is
again seen to be importing fake money will be brought to
justice," he said in a press conference. He said the interim
government "know the countries in which the money is printed
and its routes towards Somalia and with the collaboration of the
international police (Interpol) we will be able to stop it",
DPA quotes him as saying.
____________________________________________________________________________________
Businessmen
"Handed Over" Newly Printed Somali Shillings To The
Government
Mogadishu - The Somali Prime Minister, Ali Khalif
Galeyr declared yesterday that a several-hour ministerial meeting
unanimously agreed on the handing over the newly printed Somali
shillings to the Transitional Government.
In a press conference he held at Ramadan Hotel in
Mogadishu, the Somali Premier asserted that the businessmen who
printed the money reached an agreement with the government in which
the money would be transferred to the government, adding that the
government would pay the due compensation to the businessmen.
The US dollar fell sharply against the Somali
shilling today after more than 60 billion Somali shillings were
handed over to Prime Minister Galeyr by the businessmen. Economist
described this step as one taken to the right direction,
and will help ease the inflation which affected the public. (HornAfrik).
Source: HornAfrik Online
Feb 15
____________________________________________________________________________________
Interim government confiscates
fake bank notes
Feb 14 (Xog-Ogaal) - The
interim Somali prime minister, Dr Ali Khalif Galayr, held a news
conference in Mogadishu yesterday.
The premier disclosed that his
government had confiscated a good portion of the fake currency
printed recently and brought to the country by some Mogadishu
businessmen. The amount impounded was 60bn Somali shillings.
The businessmen will be
compensated for the expenses they incurred in printing the money,
the premier said. However, the premier declined to give details of
the government's compensation plan.
He said the
businessmen had agreed not to repeat the act of printing money
again, failure to which the government would take stern legal
action against those found indulging in the unethical move.
The government was
making arrangements to print its own bank notes to counter the
printing of fake bank notes by some unscrupulous business people.
"We are
concerned about the economic damage and social sufferings the fake
currency has caused the people. The move was also a big blow to
the interim government and we cannot tolerate a repeat of similar
incidents," the Premier Galayr said...
In Buro, Somaliland police have
impounded a vehicle transporting a large amount of bank notes
recently printed by Mogadishu businessmen. The Somaliland
administration termed the move as a deliberate plot to ruin and
destablize Somaliland's economy. The police have confirmed that
both the owner of the illegal money and the driver of the vehicle
were arrested and will soon be arraigned in court.
_____________________________________________________________________________________
SOMALIA:
Market dead from new currency
NAIROBI,
13 February (IRIN) - A second batch of newly printed currency has
arrived in Mogadishu. Local sources confirmed to IRIN that a
second plane-load arrived on Sunday night, believed to have been
printed in Malaysia by a cartel of Somali businessmen. "This
was part of the money that arrived on 7 February", a local
businessman told IRIN. The new notes are estimated at 90 billion
Somali shilling, or about US $6 million dollars. "This will
lead to hyper-inflation," a local economist told IRIN.
Prices
of food items and essential goods doubled when the first batch of
new money arrived on 7 February. Mogadishu residents fear that
prices will increase further. The local economist told IRIN that
the new notes had not yet been released into the market, and that
the yesterdays rate remained the same, with 15,200 Somali
shillings to US $1. He described Bakara, the main Mogadishu market
as "dead". Big traders have fixed their prices to the
dollar, but small and medium traders have stopped trading
completely, and are not selling anything, said the economist
_____________________________________________________________________________
SOMALIA:
President "upbeat" after overseas trips
NAIROBI,
6 December (IRIN) - Interim President Abdiqasim
Salad Hasan said on his return to the Somali capital Mogadishu on
Tuesday that his trips to Qatar, Sudan, Libya, Djibouti and
Ethiopia had been very successful. The president was described as
being in "the most upbeat mood since being elected",
sources close to the government told IRIN. He gave a brief speech
to supporters, and later hosted a fast-breaking dinner for a group
of people living in a camp for the displaced near his residence,
the Mogadishu-based newspapers said.
Abdiqasim's
delegation was escorted from Balidogle
airport, 90 km from Mogadishu, by 700
heavily armed militiamen on 50
trucks mounted with heavy weapons, the Associated Press
agency (AP) reported. Osman Hassan, reporter for AP, said the
heavy security presence was "a reminder of how far he [Abdiqasim]
must go to restore order in Somalia".
After
attending the IGAD meeting in Khartoum, Abdiqasim said he had made
progress in talks with regional leaders there, political sources
in Somalia said. Ethiopian Prime Minister Meles Zenawi had
suggested that Somalia's arrears be cancelled, a proposal which,
he said, was indicative of the neighbouring country's concern for
the welfare of Somalia, AP reported.
(BALIDOGLE AND THE
INFAMOUS 700 HEAVILY-ARMED MILITIA ON 50 TECHNICALS!
SAME GROUP ESCORTING
THE BILLIONS OF FAKE MONEY FROM, WHERE ELSE,
BALIDOGLE
AIRPORT! NOW YOU KNOW THE REST OF THE STORY!)
______________________________________________________________________________________
RELATED STORY: