|
DEAR NEIGHBOURS: In your darkest hour of shock, grief and
outrage, we walk with you in your collective mourning. As
your politicians and media empty their arsenal of adjectives
to convey Tuesday's catastrophe - Terror Rocks America;
Terrorist Armageddon; Pearl Harbour II - our former foreign
minister Lloyd Axworthy offers you eloquence in his simple
summation of the tragedy: The world has changed but not our
collective responses.
He suggests, as only best friends can, that you resist
the temptation to hit back, hard, at someone, anyone,
anywhere. Or build bigger walls, higher fences, hire more
guards.
It is important for your long-term security, and, by
extension, ours, that your "response be right," he
said.
So far, it has been, unlike Bill Clinton's flawed
response to the 1998 terrorist attacks on American embassies
in East Africa. American credibility took a heavy hit when
the cruise missiles he dispatched killed innocents at a
pharmaceutical factory in Sudan but missed Osama bin Laden
and his operations in Afghanistan.
Despite all the media-baiting, your current
administration has been steadfast in counselling patience
until it determines who the dead culprits were and who is
behind them.
As much as some hawks would have it, Tuesday's terrorist
attacks were not the start of the Clash of
Civilizations. "It's not one civilization or one people
attacking another, but a bunch of extremists killing
innocent civilians," Axworthy noted.
The United States needs to dig out "the root causes
and the sources of this extreme anti-American
antagonism," he said - a point also made separately by
Sandy Berger, former National Security Adviser.
To do so, America must engage with, not isolate itself
from, the world, as it has done lately, abrogating
international treaties and walking away from its
obligations.
This week's wickedly audacious attacks, annihilating
thousands, represent the dark underbelly of globalization.
Its tools - high technology, high-speed information and easy
travel - shrink geography but also empower a handful to hit
nation-states by targeting their most vulnerable spots:
easily accessible public spaces and the civilians therein.
Short of creating a garrison state that would shut down
our open democratic societies, Axworthy said, the only
sensible response is international co-operation, not
isolationism.
President George Bush and the former secretary of state
Madeleine Albright opined that America was targeted because
it is the brightest beacon of freedom and the best hope for
humanity. Perhaps. Or, maybe because it no longer pays
enough attention to those ideals and is indifferent to the
suffering of too many peoples, from Afghanistan to Chechnya
to the Middle East, if not contributing directly or
indirectly to their troubles, thus driving the ordinary folk
there to seethe in silence against America and the crazed
ones into fanatical acts.
"If you let problems fester and hope they go away
... and withdraw yourself, you pay a price for it,"
Axworthy said. That's why "as neighbours, we have to
reach out in a political way to say, `we're in this with
you. It's not the United States against the world. Let's
work together. We'll bring other countries, we will work
with countries in the Middle East ... We can help in
identification and intelligence as to the causes; work on
technical security matters; and help organize some major
international initiative to look at the broad issue.'"
On the domestic front, Americans are being told not to
rush to judgment about who may be responsible.
"We pray that Arabs are not behind it," said an
Arab American, echoing a broad sentiment in that beleaguered
community. Said another: "I hope that the culprits were
not Muslims."
Those are the voices of fear: minorities dreading a
public backlash. Not all Arabs are Muslims. Not all the
nearly 7 million American Muslims are Arabs. But in the
public mind, they are. Both groups experienced harassment
and hate during the Gulf War; in the immediate aftermath of
the Oklahoma bombing, before it was linked to Timothy
McVeigh; and are beginning to in the last 48 hours.
Given this week's far greater civilian slaughter, they
fear even worse, recalling the internment of
Japanese-Americans during World War II, and the more recent
movie Siege showing a large number of innocent Arab
Americans being rounded up following an Arab terrorist
attack.
It is instructive that such anxiety exists among
law-abiding citizens in this age of heightened awareness of
individual civil liberties and fading memories of mob rule.
It may indeed turn out that the terrorists were all
Arabs, or Muslims, or both. So what? They were no more
representatives of all Arabs or Muslims than Baruch
Goldstein was of all Jews or Irish Republican Army members
were of all Catholics.
It is revealed that some of the suspects were not
foreigners but U.S. residents. That, too, means nothing by
way of collective guilt; McVeigh did not make all Christian
Americans suspects.
So, dear Americans: Hit the terrorists hard. Be merciless
in going after them. But spare the innocents, both abroad
and at home. Which is what, to your great credit, you and
your President have done so far.
Haroon Siddiqui is The Star's editorial page editor
emeritus. His e-mail address is hsiddiq @ thestar.ca |