- Title: [SW News] (IRISH TIMES) <>LET'S JUST GET AID TO THE PEOPLE WHO NEED IT
NOW
- From:[]
- Date :[06-Apr-2000 12:00:00
am]
Last Friday, the Ethiopian Prime Minister, Meles Zenawi, made a scathing attack on the
international community for its failure to respond to appeals for food aid to stave off
famine in his country.
Western governments have in turn blamed Ethiopia for pursuing a pointless war with its
northern neighbour, Eritrea, at a time when the country is in such dire straits.
Both arguments are irrelevant when eight million people are staring death in the face.
The number at risk can be doubled when six other countries in the Horn of Africa are taken
into account.
Drought is the primary cause for the current food crisis. Underlying factors include
the cumulative effects of poor and unreliable rainfall and other shocks which have eroded
assets and coping strategies in the last three years.
There are two rainy seasons in Ethiopia, the Belg and Meher, both crucial to food
production. Before the Belg rain period, which falls in March and April, it was estimated
that 850,000 tonnes of food would be needed for this year alone. With their failure, the
requirement is now closer to a million tonnes.
A United Nations inter-agency appeal was made for dollars 190 million to finance the
purchase of this food; about half that amount has been received. The US has sent a ship
with 84,000 tonnes of grain but that will not arrive at Djibouti until April 19th. It is
also reported that in some pastoral areas up to 90 per cent of cattle and 65 per cent of
goats are dying from lack of food and water. This further contributes to the
disintegration of the food infrastructure of the country.
In addition to the problem of acquiring enough money and food to solve the obvious
problem of famine, there are huge problems of logistics associated with its distribution.
Ethiopia is landlocked since Eritrea received its independence in the early 1990s.
The state of war means that shipping grain through the Eritrean ports of Assab and
Massawa, which would be the normal access points, is not an option. This means that the
only alternatives are Djibouti and possibly the port of Berbera in Somalia. The problem with the latter is
that the roads in Somalia are mined and the country is in a state of anarchy with large areas
controlled by warlords in a permanent state of conflict. This leaves Djibouti as the only
viable route but the capacity of the port is only in the region of 4,000 to 5,000 tonnes a
day. Considering that the requirement is more than a million tonnes, the bottleneck that
this constitutes is formidable.
While vast areas of the north, central and south-eastern parts of Ethiopia have been
devastated by the drought, some food is believed to be available in the south-west. The
government has put out a tender for 100,000 tonnes of grain but private contractors with
state farms have only come up with 9,000 tonnes. The suspicion is that merchants are
withholding stocks to get a higher price as the crisis worsens. It is also possible that
some stocks could be bought in northern Sudan but Ethiopians are not well disposed to this
because of complex political disputes which bedevil the Horn of Africa.
Both the current disaster and a famine which killed 800,000 people in 1984 were caused
by failure of the rains, but this time more people are at risk because of population
growth. As the population has increased, the land has been divided into even smaller
parcels. The soil has become more overworked, leading to weaker yields. The result is that
many millions of people, particularly in the central highlands and the Ogaden region, are
literally destitute and in a state of permanent food insecurity.
Their coping capacity is so diminished that they cannot now deal with even minor
shocks.
So to what extent is the Ethiopian government culpable? It is true it is engaged in a
pointless war with Eritrea over 150 square miles of land along the border in an area known
as the Badme Triangle. It is true it is difficult to deal with and very bureaucratic. One
example is its attitude to NGOs. Concern has worked in Ethiopia for the best part of 20
years and we had, at one time, significant assets in that country.
We had more than 20 trucks but were made to dispose of most of them to the private
sector. The theory was that, in the event of an emergency, the capacity would exist in the
private sector to deal with it without the help of outsiders. This is fine in theory but
not in practice.
The trucks are not available now that they are needed and we have to try to get
permission from the government to build up our capacity to respond to the impending
famine. All other NGOs and UN agencies were treated the same way.
To give it its due, the government did try to make the country less vulnerable to
climatic disasters. It put in place a sophisticated early-warning system to predict
rainfall and crop production so that appeals for food aid could be made in good time. As a
direct result of the 1984 famine, the government normally holds 350,000 tonnes of food in
reserve to enable it to respond rapidly to any shortage. That reserve is now almost
exhausted.
The government appealed for additional food aid as long ago as November but the
response was poor. This was partly because institutional donors were dealing with so many
other crises but to an extent it was also a negative reaction to the war and a fear that
aid would be diverted to the military.
The EU failed to meet its commitment last year, providing little more than half the
food it promised. It is now more than a year behind on its pledges. This year it pledged
only 50,000 tonnes (compared with 480,000 pledged by the US). It is hoped that some
positive utterances by the EU Development Commissioner, Poul Nielson, this week indicated
that the EU has received its wake-up call.
Recriminations at this time serve no purpose. The war is a factor but the massive
humanitarian catastrophe about to unfold owes its cause mainly to drought and poverty.
Eight million people are at serious risk and all the stops have to be pulled out to help
them. I believe the following needs to be done:
The international community must immediately provide the million tonnes of food needed
and get it on the high seas;
There must be an immediate armistice to allow humanitarian aid to flow into Ethiopia
through the Eritrean ports.
If necessary, an airlift should be considered to bridge the gap until food can arrive
by sea;
Every effort must be made to source food from northern Sudan and from those parts of
Ethiopia where there may be some surplus. The Ethiopian government must not obstruct this;
The UN agencies and the NGOs must be given the freedom to operate, albeit in
consultation with the government, and be allowed to take in whatever human and material
resources they need. Extensive use should be made of NGO capacity for distribution to
guarantee that aid is not diverted for military use.
Concern has allocated (pounds) 500,000 to pre-position high protein supplementary food,
shelter materials, blankets and medical supplies. Our job is to get the food in and make
serious preparations for healthcare and water provision. We will also seek ways of
combining with other agencies to maximise our impact. This crisis will test the
humanitarian aid community to the limit.
The journalist and author Michael Ignatieff wrote a book called The Warriors' Honour a
couple of years ago. It deals with the humanitarian consequences of war and famine. The
first chapter opens with these words about the 1984 Ethiopian Famine:
The British nurse was picking her way through the mass of women and children squatting
in the dust at the entrance to the field hospital of the refugee camp at Koren in
Ethiopia. She was selecting which children could still be helped, she was choosing who
would live and who would die. A television crew trailed behind her, moving its way among
the starving. A reporter approached her with a mike and asked her how she felt about what
she was doing. It was not a question she felt capable of answering. The look she gave the
camera came from very far away.
We are in a race against time to prevent this tragedy being repeated.
David Begg is the chief executive of Concern
[ News] |